Showing 15 results for Monetary Policy
Soheila Parvin, Ehsan Taherifard,
Volume 8, Issue 4 (1-2009)
Abstract
The aim of this paper is to investigate empirically the effects of monetary policy on poverty and income distribution in Iran using the data over the period 1976-2005. Monetary policy is one of the most potent instruments for managing the economy. There is a useful question to ask if the monetary policy is used as an instrument to reduce poverty. Most of the existing literature on monetary policy and poverty focuses on the short run. Monetary policy affects most of the macroeconomic variables such as output, unemployment, and inflation. Moreover, anticipated inflation and unanticipated inflation redistribute differently income from creditors to debtors. If poverty and inequality respond to these macroeconomic variables, monetary policy affects the well-being of the poor.
The findings of this study show that monetary policy cannot be used as a poverty alleviation policy in Iran, since the expansionary monetary policy followed commonly by expansionary fiscal policy results in a rise in budget deficits. This policy increases the aggregate demand for all the goods and services in the economy resulting in higher inflation. Furthermore, there is no significant link between monetary policy and investment through interest rate. Consequently, monetary policy has no supply side effects in the economy and just it increases inflation rate. As a result of expansionary monetary policy, the poor would find its real income being gradually eroded by the growth in money supply, and hence the possibility of running into poverty.
Morteza Khorsandi, Karim Eslamloueyan, Hossein Zonnoor,
Volume 12, Issue 1 (5-2012)
Abstract
Monetary conditions index (MCI) is used as an intermediate target of monetary policy in many developed countries. More recently, monetary authorities in some developing countries have also attempted to use this operational target to determine the stance of monetary policy in their countries. The MCI is usually computed as a weighted sum of changes in interest rate and exchange rate. The use of interest rate in constructing MCI might not be appropriate in developing countries due to the lack of efficient financial markets in these countries. Some authors have emphasized on the role of credit channel in monetary transmission mechanism for developing countries. Using weighted sum of profit rate, exchange rate and banks credit, this paper constructs proper MCI for the Iranian economy. Aggregate demand and price equations are used to estimate the weights. Finally, the forecasting power of these indices using non-nested tests and root mean square errors is compared. The results show that the MCI augmented with banks credit has better predicting power than those without credit channel. Moreover, it is also revealed that real MCI, as an intermediate target, is preferred to nominal ones.
Kazem Farahmand Gelyan, Nasser Shahnoushi,
Volume 13, Issue 2 (7-2013)
Abstract
Today, policymakers and economists use widely rational expectations (RE) in monetary, financial and regulatory policies to improve their country economic performance. In some of the pertinent models to these policies, expectations have been formed by assuming rationality and full information on economics. Indeed, economic agents have no perfect information about some parameters of these models. These unknown parameters can be estimated in the form rational expectations during learning process. In this research, the impact of government policies on the inflation rate has been modeled on the basis of rational expectations under learning process. Data has been gathered from Central Bank of Iran (CBI) and Iran’s economic development plans over the period 1989-2009. Results show that current inflation in the country originates mainly from economy structure and government policies, so share of public inflationary expectations is negligible. In addition, the learning process in Iran will converge to rational expectations, thus government policies for reducing inflation and increasing employment are inefficient. It is recommended that government adopt unanticipated and sudden policies to be effective its plans.
Akbar Komijani, Hamid Reza Tabatabaee Zavareh,
Volume 15, Issue 1 (4-2015)
Abstract
Regarding the differences among firms on financial position and access to various financial resources, the selection of a proper variable, which represents actual cost of capital of a firm, is of great importance in explaining the firms demand for money. In order to improve the estimation of interest rate elasticity of demand for money by manufacturing firms, this paper computes the cost of capital for each firm. Using firm level panel data for 161 manufacturing companies listed in Tehran Stock Exchange, the demand for money is estimated over the period 2000 to 2010. It is found that (a) the firms in which the cost of capital is higher, have low real balances; (b) the average cost of capital and its variations implies that the weight of cost of capital should be reexamined by monetary authority; and (c) the sensitivity of demand for money to fluctuations in wage is more than to interest rate.
Zarifeh Jalili, Abbas Asari Arani, Kazem Yavari, Hassan Heydari,
Volume 17, Issue 4 (3-2018)
Abstract
Expansion of financial markets including capital market is a key factor in increasing investment, which affects significantly the economic growth and development. Any change in monetary policy will influence real sector of economy, prices and returns on stocks. The performance of stock market is of considerable effect on macro economy, and plays substantial role in the monetary policy transmission process. In this paper, we examine the effect of monetary policy on the stock market using a five-variable structural vector auto-regressive model by applying monthly data during March 2005 to March 2013. The results suggest that the monetary policy through liquidity and loans directed to private sector is of significantly positive effect on the stock market index. As a result, expansionary monetary policy by increasing the liquidity and loans directed to the private sector improves stock market general index. In addition, changes in monetary policy through exchange rate and real interest rate have significant and negative effects on this index. The contractionary monetary policy through interest rate improves stock market index. Finally, shocks resulting from changes in exchange rate exacerbate the monetary policy in the short term, which in turn worsen the stock market index.
Zahra Afshari, Hossein Tavakolian, Marziyeh Bayat,
Volume 18, Issue 2 (7-2018)
Abstract
This article attempts to examine the impact of stock market fluctuations on macroeconomic variables by designing a New Keynesian approach in a dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) model. For this purpose, first, model parameters are estimated based on Bayesian approach and using of quarterly data from 1994 to 2014. Second, the impulse response functions of variables to innovations in stock price index, monetary shock, technology shock, consumer spending and public investment are investigated. Then, the optimal weights related to inflation gap, output gap and the stock price index gap within the monetary policy function are extracted. According to the results, a shock to stock price index has a negligible effect on inflation and output variables. This may be due to the small size of the stock market in Iran. Finally, the optimal coefficients are determined for inflation and output gaps, stock price index gap, and the central bank deadweight loss under various scenarios. Based on findings, first, the central bank should attribute more weight to inflation in itself reaction functions. Second, a scenario in which the weight of stock price index is zero has less deadweight loss, thus the response of the central bank to stock price index gap leads to a reduction in social welfare. Therefore, when the stock market is booming, the central bank is recommended not to be intervened to reduce liquidity.
Mr. Ali Akbar Bajelan, Rouhollah Bayat, Dr Habib Ansari Samani,
Volume 18, Issue 4 (12-2018)
Abstract
Monetary policy is an effective tool in influencing the macroeconomic variables such as production, employment and the general level of prices. The theoretical literature and empirical evidence show that the effects of monetary policy on macroeconomic variables are asymmetric depending on the level of development and depth of financial markets. The aim of this study is to evaluate the role of financial development in the effectiveness of monetary policy on real output growth during business cycles. To this end, the effect of monetary policy on the real output growth is examined by applying a Markov-switching model and using the quarterly time-series data of Iran during 2001:1 to 2013:4. The results show that the effect of monetary policy on the real output growth during the recessions is significant and positive, while it is insignificant in the boom periods. In other words, the effect of monetary policy on the real output growth is asymmetric. Moreover, the results show that the net effect of monetary policy on the real output growth during business cycles depend on the level of financial development. During business cycles, if the level of financial development increases, then the effects of monetary policy on real output growth will decrease.
Dr Alireza Erfani, Dr Hossein Tavakolian, Azadeh Talebbeydokhti,
Volume 18, Issue 4 (12-2018)
Abstract
Today, achieving financial stability alongside stabilizing inflation and output is of particular importance among monetary policymakers and regulatory authorities. In this study, a Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Model was used for the period 1990: 1 to 2014: 4 in the economy of Iran, in which a measure of financial shock was also introduced. In this model, the financial shock is modeled as a reduction in external financing premium of the firm. Comparison of the performance of policy rules showed that following an expansionary financial shock, macro-prudential policy regime, in which instruments of monetary policy and macro-prudential policy deal with excessive growth of credit, leads to a significant reduction in the external financing premium of the firm. This in turn leads to less volatility in economic variables, such as inflation and output. This would improve the welfare in the Economy of Iran.
Parviz Davoodi, Mr. Mohammad Sarlab,
Volume 19, Issue 2 (6-2019)
Abstract
Improving the distribution of income is one of the main goals of governments in economic policy, regardless of the orientation of different systems. The purpose of this study is to investigate the distributive effects of monetary policy on income distribution in urban and rural areas of Iran. In this regard, the values of macroeconomic variables during the period of 1959-2014 and the household budget data over the period of 1997-2014 were used. The monetary policy was considered in three scenarios, including the increase in facilities granted to the private sector, the decrease in the reserve requirement ratio and decrease in the excess reserves ratio. The results showed that expansionary monetary policy improves the distribution of income in the short run, but in the long run it worsens the distribution of income due to its inflationary effect. An increase in facilities granted in the short term reduces the Gini coefficient in urban and rural areas, and whole country. However, it increases the Gini coefficients in all three sections in the long run. Reducing the reserve requirement ratio in the short run reduces Gini coefficients, but it does not change the whole Gini coefficient in the long run, but it increases the Gini coefficients in urban and rural areas. The effect of reducing excess reserves ratio is similar to that of reducing reserve requirement ratio.
Mr. Mohammadjavad Khosrosereshki, Dr Reza Najarzadeh, Dr Hassan Heydari,
Volume 22, Issue 2 (6-2022)
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to investigate the impact of adding a non-Ricardian household to a DSGE model in choosing the Ramsey optimal monetary policy and consequently the effects on macroeconomic variables (such as output gap, consumption gap, inflation, and rising nominal exchange rate). Therefore, after estimating a model for the Iranian economy, the Ramsey optimal monetary policy was selected from 6 monetary policy alternatives. Then, in two scenarios, a non-Ricardian household is added to the model. In the first scenario, the non-Ricardian household consists of 20% of households and in the second, it consists of 40% of households. Then, Ramsey optimal monetary policy was selected for these two scenarios. The results show that the when the percentage of non-Ricardian households in the model increases, monetary policy-maker deviates from targeting monetary variables and gives more importance to production targeting. Second, if Ramsey optimal monetary policy is chosen without considering the non-Ricardian household in the model, in facing the shock of falling oil prices, the shock of declining money demand and the shock of rising external inflation, the responses of the production and consumption sectors in scenarios 1 and 2 are significantly different from the baseline model. But the consumption and production sectors have almost the same reactions in three models in response to the shock of the rising nominal exchange rate.
Mr. Alireza Zarifian Abhari, Dr Parastoo Mohammadi,
Volume 23, Issue 1 (3-2023)
Abstract
Aim and Introduction:
The distribution of income and wealth in Iran is highly dependent on monetary policy. Iran's macroeconomic variables show that the country is experiencing an increase in inflation, liquidity and social inequality. Given that the facility repayment rate plays a role in channeling resources to investments, and given the role of the central bank in determining and regulating this variable in Iran, this study examines the impact of changing the facility repayment rate as a monetary policy tool on macroeconomics variables related to the distribution of income and wealth in society. The contribution of this research is to provide the agent-based model for Iran and to study the effects of different scenarios of decreasing, increasing and constant trend of facility repayment rate on the distribution of income and wealth, and other macroeconomic variables.
Methodology:
Two types of approaches can be used to model this problem: (1) simulation with the Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium (DSGE) approach and (2) simulation with the Agent-based Computational Economics (ACE) approach. DSGE models seek to find the optimal point, in which pricing is done through aggregating supply and demand by the Walrasian auctioneer, and none of the factors can decide on their variables. While in ACE simulations, changing process of variables and factors is examined and each factor has the ability to decide about its variables based on its observation of the system. The ACE approach has been used because of the proximity of the simulation to reality and the ability to examine the process. In this simulation, the effect of changing the facility repayment rate on the distribution of income and wealth and other macroeconomic variables is examined in three scenarios: decreasing, increasing and fixed facility repayment rate.
Agents that are considered in the proposed simulation are: (1) The Central bank as policy-maker agent that decides about facility repayment rate and money supply volume, (2) The bank is responsible for allocating credit to firms and depositing from households and distributing income from banking activities among depositors. It is also the responsibility of the bank to sell consumer goods and capital of bankrupt companies that have not been able to repay their facilities, (3) Firms are responsible for the production of consumer goods and capital and its sale in the market, and (4) A household that provides its labor force to firms in exchange for wages and provides consumer goods for its livelihood in the consumer goods market. In this simulation, policy-making is done by the central bank and the existence of the government, and fiscal policies are ignored and only the mentioned monetary policy (facility repayment rate) is investigated.
In this research, the market is defined in a way that each agent on the demand side observes a random list in terms of number of factors on the supply side and buys from the supplier agent that offers the lowest price. Model have 4 markets as follows: (1) the labor market, (2) consumer goods market, (3) capital goods market, and (4) credit market. The characteristic of this type of market is that the market mechanism is a random adaptation mechanism, and all agents on the demand side have incomplete information from suppliers and vice versa. None of agents see all the market prices and decide to buy only on the basis of incomplete observations of the system. Also, on the supplier side, the firm does not see the cumulative need of the market. It means that the firm estimates the amount of production for this period based solely on its own personal experience in the previous periods, and according to that estimate, it employs labor and produces goods and services. And firms set prices based on their experience on previous periods. This kind of market attitude in simulation has caused the simulated market to be closer to the real world.
Results and Discussion:
The result of this simulation shows that the repayment rate of incremental scenario caused the collapse of the simulation system and also the Gini coefficient increased, which indicates the disparity in the distribution of income and wealth in society. The fixed scenario does not show an effect on improving the Gini coefficient and on the other hand causes the bankruptcy of many firms in the long run. The best result is the reducing scenario. In this scenario, the system achieved sustainable economic growth, controlled liquidity, and a reduction in the Gini coefficient.
Conclusion:
In the absence of speculative markets, all the money generated in the banking system is directed to the production and development of economic activities. In addition, decreasing repayment rate of facilities can improve the distribution of income and wealth in society.
Dr Leila Torki, Mrs. Vala Sanizadeh,
Volume 23, Issue 1 (3-2023)
Abstract
Aim and Introduction:
The choice between interest rate and money supply as the objective of monetary policy has always been a question in economic literature. Based on the results of many economic studies, the interest rate is a more appropriate target. Due to the instability of the demand for money, since the mid-1980s, the money supply has lost its generality, and instead, the use of interest rates has been used.
In Iran's economy, due to the prohibition of using bonds because of their usurious nature and determining the interest rates of bank deposits in a mandatory manner, it has not been possible to use the interest rate as the goal of monetary policy in recent years. In most of the researches, the monetary base growth rate is used as the target of the central bank's monetary policy.
This research tries to use dynamic stochastic general equilibrium approach in Iran, to examine the effects of implementing monetary policy through the regulated interbank interest rate and transaction of government debt securities and to compare its effects on the macroeconomic variables with the effects of common monetary policy of the central bank (setting the growth rate of the monetary base through changing the rate legal reserve).
Methodology:
In this research, a stochastic dynamic general equilibrium model of an open economy has been designed to analyze the effects of different monetary policy regimes on the macro variables of the Iranian economy. This model analyzes the characteristics of the Iranian economy such as the dependency on oil revenues, the persistent budget deficit and the misalignment of central bank's balance sheet. Also, based on the new Keynesian school, price stickiness has been considered in the model by Calvo's method (1983) for domestic, import and export intermediary companies.
Results and Discussion:
According to the graphs of impulse-response functions, as a result of the positive impulse of the interbank interest rate, the demand of banks for borrowing and the monetary base are reduced. The bank resources are limited, and the facilities granted to the companies are reduced. Due to the stability of the company's demand, as a result of the additional demand for facilities, the interest rate of the facilities will increase.
By reducing the facilities granted to companies, the company must hire fewer factors based on optimization due to the higher cost of financing. The demand and wages of household labor will decrease. Due to the decrease in the demand for labor and capital by the company, the non-oil production also decreases. As a result, the inflation rate increases with the decrease in supply. On the other hand, with an increase in the real interest rate based on Euler's relationship and a decrease in household income due to a decrease in wages and employment of labor by companies, consumer spending decreases. Therefore, in response to the decrease in the demand of the whole economy, the price level gradually decreases and the economy returns to equilibrium. Due to the fact that in the model, imports are limited to consumer goods, with the reduction of household consumption expenses, imports also decrease.
According to the graphs of the impulse response function, with the increase in the growth rate of the monetary base, the resources available to banks increase, and bank facilities get available to companies in order to cover expenses. The facilities granted to the companies will increase, and due to the constant demand of the company, the cost of financing will decrease by reducing the interest rate of the facilities. As a result of optimization, by reducing the final cost of hiring agents, the company should employ more agents. So, the demand for household labor will increase. By hiring more factors by the company, non-oil production in the economy increases after impulse.
Conclusion:
The positive impulse of the interest rate of the interbank market (as a contractionary policy of the central bank) has a negative effect on the non-oil production by increasing the cost of financing of companies and reducing the facilities granted. As the supply of the entire economy decreases, the inflation rate also increases after the impulse is applied.
The positive momentum of the growth rate of the monetary base (as the central bank's expansionary policy) is expected to increase the lending of banks, and to reduce the interest rate of the facilities, if bank resources increase.
By comparing these impulse response functions under the application of each monetary policy regime, it seems that the effect of the impulse of the monetary base growth rate compared to the impulse of the interbank interest rate on the economy disappears in shorter periods.
These results are expected due to the fact that the targeting of interbank interest rates has less effect on the macroeconomic variables in Iran due to the restrictions on the issuance of government debt bonds and the implementation of open market operations by the central bank.
Mrs. Mina Naderi, Dr Arash Hadizadeh, Dr Akbar Mirzapour Babajan,
Volume 23, Issue 2 (5-2023)
Abstract
Introduction
In developing countries, the shocks that enter the economy due to capital market fluctuations have more depth and durability. Because of the two-way connection between the stock market and the real sector of the economy and public attention to this market, examining the stock market shocks is of great importance. Therefore, the present study investigated the extreme fluctuations of the stock market index, which suspected the existence of bubbles. Timing of these bubbles in the market is one of the goals of this study, which was carried out by using the right-tailed unit root tests based on the augmented Dickey-Fuller test. A stock price bubble may be affected by monetary policy. This issue is influenced by the size of the bubble and the type and strength of the applied monetary policy. The impact of monetary policy fluctuations and especially interest rates on stock price bubbles is theoretically uncertain and should be determined empirically. Therefore, another goal of this study is to examine the effects of monetary policy shocks on the formation and timing of the stock market bubble.
Methodology
The method of Phillips et al. (2015) has been used to identify and time the stock market bubble. Galli and Gambeti model and TVP-SVAR method were also used to investigate the effect of monetary policy on the stock market bubble.
Results and Discussion
BSADF (Backward Supreme Augmented Dicky-Fuller) test has been used to determine the dates when the stock market had a bubble. According to this test, in three short periods, from July to September 2005, from April to May 2011, and from October to November 2018, the stock market behaved like a bubble. Regarding the impact of the interest rate shock on the stock market bubble, it can be said that the monetary expansion shock (decrease in the real interest rate) causes the bubble part of the stock price to become larger. In all periods, the response of the bubble part was positive, but over time, has increased, and since the beginning of the 2010s, its response to the shock of interest rate reduction has completely changed. The liquidity shock, also strengthens the size of the bubble. The amount of this influence has also increased greatly over time and has reached its peak in 2017 (the year of the formation of the price bubble in the stock market based on the BSADF test). Therefore, it can be claimed that the increase in the bubble part of the stock price was caused by a positive shock or an increase in liquidity. Regarding the effect of the credit shock on the stock market bubble, it can be said that credits has affected the fundamental part of the stock price, but it does not have much effect on the bubble part of the stock price. In fact, the increase in credits has caused the liquidity restrictions of economic enterprises to be removed and has an effect on their production and sales and finally on their profitability. Therefore, it is expected that with an increase in credits (positive credit shock), most of the fundamental part (current and future profitability) of companies will be affected.
Conclusion
During the last decade, the public attention to the stock market in Iran increased significantly. This issue caused the entry of new funds into this market, which was seen in the bubble-like behavior of the stock price index. In the conventional economic theory, the positive impact of expansionary monetary policies on the bubble is expected, but there are other theories that make the long-term impact of the monetary policy shock on the size of the bubble uncertain and dependent on factors such as the size of the bubble, the stability of the monetary policy, and the type of monetary tool. In order to solve this theoretical ambiguity, the effect of one of these cases, i.e., changing the monetary policy tool, on the stock price bubble was investigated. Before that, the existence of a bubble in the stock market had been checked. Regarding the impact of monetary shocks on the stock price bubble, according to the type of monetary policy instrument, the reaction of the stock price bubble has been different. Interest rate policy and liquidity have had a positive effect on the bubble, but credit policy has not had such an effect. In most of the developed economies, the interest rate change is the most powerful monetary policy tool, as a small change in it can have a large impact on the real sector of these economies. But in our country, according to the empirical findings of this article, the effect of liquidity on the stock market bubbles has been greater than the effect of changing the interest rates on it. This result is a proof of the dominance of liquidity over monetary policies in Iran.
Keywords: Monetary policy, interest rate, liquidity, stock market price bubble, Vector Autoregressive with Time Varying Parameter
JEL Classification: C22, E32, E44, G14
Mrs Shokooh Mahmoodi, Dr. Seyed Abdulmajid Jalaee, Dr Zeinolabedin Sadeghi, Dr Alireza Shakibai,
Volume 24, Issue 1 (3-2024)
Abstract
Introduction
Currently, 87 countries – representing more than 90% of global GDP – are considering central bank digital currency (CBDC). It is therefore crucial that central banks understand the implications of CBDCs for financial stability and monetary policy. CBDCs should not harm the country's economy. In particular, they should not become a source of financial disruption that could disrupt the transmission of monetary policy. Recently, the details of the Central Bank's digital currency, which is called "Digital Rial" in Iran, have been published by the Central Bank of Iran. This study seeks to examine the changes in the country's monetary policies with the introduction of the Digital Rial by the Central Bank using the system dynamics method. The results of this study show that with the issue of the Digital Rial, the increasing coefficient of money decreases and reduces the money supply, and because the Digital Rial has the same nature as banknotes and coins, it can reduce the power of banks in creating liquidity. As a result, the central bank can use Digital Rial as contractionary monetary policy tool to control inflation in the country.
Methodology:
In order to provide a working solution for the research problem and to understand the importance of the topic, this study tries to use the system dynamics method to present a dynamic model of the relationship between digital currencies and its effect on monetary policies in Iran's economy. System dynamics is a method for modeling systems using accumulation, state and flow variables, which was developed in the 1960s by Professor Jay Forrester at MIT University. This model became very famous in the 70s thanks to the publication of the book "Limits to Growth". This book used the system dynamics model to analyze the absurdity of the idea of unlimited growth. Today, the most comprehensive source for the system dynamics model is the book "Business Dynamics" by Professor John Sterman (2000, MIT University). System dynamics can model the technical and social aspects of complex systems created by the adoption of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. The idea of interaction between factors related to human behavior and the (technical) framework of the system is a perfect way to study the economic dynamics of this new form of money.
Results and Discussion:
The results showed that with the issue of Digital Rial, the increasing coefficient of money decreases and money supply decreases, and because the Digital Rial has the same nature as banknotes and coins, it can reduce the power of banks to create liquidity. On the other hand, the estimates of this research showed that the effect of the ratio of banknotes and coins on the increasing coefficient was not significant, and also the increasing coefficient had less effect on the money supply in pre-2013 period, which can be attributed to the effect of the increasing effect of the money supply. Most of the banks know that in increasing the country's liquidity, the use and expansion of the Digital Rial as a contractionary monetary policy tool will be effective in the current economic conditions. Also, this effect can be more effective with the increase in the use of electronic payments and new banking methods, because in addition to facilitating exchanges and reducing money printing costs, the use of Digital Rials also has the advantages of current electronic payments, with the difference that this part of deposits is not under the control of banks and is kept in electronic wallets, so they will not have the power to create liquidity. Therefore, the effectiveness of this money depends on the choice of the central bank to deposit electronic wallets in commercial banks, as well as the volume of this money issue.
Conclusion:
Considering the effect of Digital Rial on monetary contraction, it is suggested to design effective incentives in the design of Digital Rial, because the expansion of the use of this currency can be effective in controlling inflation. Among these incentives, we can mention fixed fees and lower taxes in transactions compared to other means of payments or increasing the limit of convertible money. Also, the requirement to purchase certain goods only through Digital Rial and to designate special shopping centers that only pay with Digital Rial (similar to China's policies on the use of Chinese Yuan by people) can also be other incentives to use Digital Rial. Also, due to the facilitation and acceleration of exchanges, the expansion of the Digital Rial can be effective in controlling the money supply besides the advantages of electronic payment methods.
Mr Mousa Maghsoudi, Dr Mansour Zarra-Nezhad, Dr Masoud Khodapanah,
Volume 25, Issue 1 (3-2025)
Abstract
Aim and Introduction
Studies and contributions of structural vector autoexplanatory models using Bayesian and classical techniques have provided evidence that shocks to the marginal efficiency of investment are the main drivers of economic volatility in US postwar data. However, dynamic stochastic general equilibrium models attempt to explain the movement of consumption with production following a marginal efficiency of investment (MEI) shock. Indeed, the decline in consumption after a positive MEI shock contradicts empirically identified business cycles. This issue is referred to as the consumption puzzle. In other words, consumption usually decreases after a positive investment shock in the model. Therefore, the usual DSGE models do not produce the observed co-movement between macroeconomic variables in response to the marginal efficiency of investment shock. From an empirical perspective, consumption, investment, working hours and production all move together. This lack of coordination of consumption in response to investment shocks is problematic as an important source of business cycles.
A review of empirical studies indicates that investment shocks and consumption puzzle have received limited attention. In this regard, the main aim and innovation of the current study is to set up a dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) model and use the Bayesian approach for Iran in order to bridge this study gap as much as possible.
The marginal efficiency of investment shock is a source of exogenous changes in the efficiency with which the final good can be converted into physical capital and thus into future capital input. This change may be due to technological factors specific to the production of investment goods. On the other hand, exogenous changes in efficiency can result from disturbances in the process of converting these investment goods into productive capital.
In neoclassical models, after a positive MEI shock, households trading in
financial markets increase their investment and reduce consumption. In fact, an intertemporal substitution effect occurs between the current consumption and investment, which creates a negative wealth effect and, therefore, creates the so-called consumption puzzle. The mechanism behind the puzzle was first described by Barrow and King (1984). The idea is that if an efficient equilibrium exists, the marginal rate of substitution between consumption and leisure should equal the marginal product of labor. This condition implies that with exogenous shocks that only indirectly affect marginal production labor, as MEI shocks actually do, consumption and labor hours move in opposite directions. Therefore, although MEI shocks account for up to 60% of the variance in output and working hours, the argument that investment shocks are one of the most important drivers of macroeconomic fluctuations is challenging.
Methodology
The core of current research model is derived from the studies of Rohe (2012) and by expanding it, the marginal efficiency of investment shock and the consumption puzzle have been modeled for Iran.
To estimate the model parameters, the Bayesian method, and the Random Walk Metropolis-Hastings algorithm were used. The data of the model’s observable variables include seasonal adjusted data, gross domestic production, private consumption, private investment, government expenditure, and inflation rate (gross) from 2004 to 2022, which underwent a de-trending procedure using the Hodrick-Prescott filter.
Findings
The marginal efficiency of investment shock leads to an increase in the rate of return on capital and investment. Consumption behavior is similar to investment behavior but with less volatility. Due to the increase in the demand side of the economy, inflation will increase and the real exchange rate will decrease. In response to the increase in the demand side, production, wage rates and employment increase. It should be noted that the contractionary monetary policy has led to a reduction in the fluctuations of macroeconomic variables, yet the dynamic of the variables has not changed.
Discussion and Conclusion
In justifying these results, the average mark-up equation of the economy can be used:
Mup,t=MPNtWtPt
where, Mup,t is the average mark-up, MPNt is the marginal product of labor, Wt is the nominal wage rate and Pt is the price index in period t.
The equilibrium conditions of the labor market can also be introduced as follows:
1Mup,tMPNtNt=MRStCt , Nt
Despite nominal price stickiness, firms are not able to increase their prices in response to the increase in demand caused by the investment boom resulted from shocks. Therefore, the average mark-up of the economy decreases and effectively shifts the labor demand curve upwards. In this situation, consumption and working hours increase. In other words, in spite of inseparable preferences and in the conditions that the increase of working hours has a positive effect on the marginal utility of consumption (the complementarity of working hours and consumption), the co-movement of investment, production, working hours and consumption can be justified and the puzzle of consumption does not occur